West Alexandria Homes for Sale

Welcome to West Alexandria, Ohio – a charming small town that perfectly blends the tranquility of rural living with the convenience of modern amenities. Nestled in the heart of Preble County, West Alexandria is known for its friendly community, picturesque landscapes, and rich history. With a population that embraces the values of togetherness and neighborly support, this delightful town is an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle.

As you explore West Alexandria, you'll discover a variety of local shops, parks, and recreational activities that foster a strong sense of community. The town is surrounded by scenic farmland, offering stunning views and ample opportunities for outdoor adventures, from hiking and biking to fishing and picnicking. Additionally, the nearby Twin Creek offers a beautiful backdrop for your weekend getaways.

When it comes to real estate, West Alexandria boasts a diverse selection of homes for sale, catering to various tastes and budgets. Whether you’re searching for a charming historic home, a cozy cottage, or a modern family residence, you’ll find something that suits your needs. Many properties feature spacious yards, perfect for gardening or outdoor gatherings, while others are conveniently located near local amenities.

Investing in a home in West Alexandria means becoming part of a close-knit community that values connection and quality of life. With affordable housing options and a welcoming atmosphere, now is the perfect time to explore the homes for sale in this delightful Ohio town. Embrace the charm of West Alexandria and discover your dream home today!

Newest West Alexandria Homes for Sale

$239,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 963986 MLS ⋅ Linda Hendershot

If you are looking for a move in ready, completely remodeled home, this is it! This 2 bed, 1 bath home is situated on a corner lot with metal carport, new 12X20 lawn shed w/concrete ramp and beautiful custom landscaping & lawn. The custom kitchen boasts wood cabinets, crown molding, brand new SS appliances, granite counter tops, large SS single bowl sink, vented out oven hood, trash bin and garbage disposal. The open floor plan allows for cooking and entertaining with family and friends. The entire home features LED recessed lighting w/dimmers, custom light fixtures, exterior soffit lighting on a timer, linen closet in bathroom, coat closet at front door and more! The bedrooms are spacious with ample natural lighting, large closets and all interior walls insulated for soundproofing. This is a very high efficiency home with gas Lennox HE furnace and AC, R-50 insulation in the attic, natural gas Tankless hot water heater and all exterior walls have new insulation and fire stopping. The laundry area has utility closet, water softener, closet for stacked washer/dryer, cabinets for storage w/granite countertop. The new bathroom features wood cabinets, granite counter top, comfort height toilet and wainscoting. Exterior has new metal roof, house wrap, new sidewalks/steps, new siding, windows and doors. Don't miss an opportunity to live in this beautiful energy efficient home, save on utility bills while enjoying a gorgeous lawn and landscaping! The carport will house a full size pickup truck, it's 20' X 11' X 7.6" high. The new 12X20 lawn shed has electric (buried), a designated electric panel, GFCI outlets and nice lighting inside and out! Make an appointment today!

40 E 2nd Street, West Alexandria

Courtesy of Linda Hendershot and Coldwell Banker Heritage

$139,900

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 963516 MLS ⋅ Joni Schumann

Discover an exceptional opportunity to embrace serene living at this charming single-family residence, perfectly situated in the heart of West Alexandria. This delightful home offers a harmonious blend of comfort and practicality, inviting residents to create lasting memories within its welcoming walls. The property presents a lifestyle of ease and accessibility, nestled in a community known for its tranquil atmosphere. Step inside to find a thoughtfully designed layout encompassing 1,080 square feet of living space, ideal for both relaxation and entertaining. This residence features four comfortable bedrooms and one full bathroom. The story and a half design ensures convenient living, while a welcoming porch enhances the home's curb appeal and offers a lovely spot for outdoor enjoyment. Situated on a generous 0.81-acre lot, the expansive outdoor space provides endless possibilities for gardening, recreation, or simply unwinding amidst nature's beauty. Additionally a large out building is also included. This property represents an outstanding value in a desirable location, presenting a unique chance to experience the peaceful charm of West Alexandria living.

31 Quaker Trace Road, West Alexandria

Courtesy of Joni Schumann and Irongate Inc.

$209,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 960468 MLS ⋅ Tracey Bitonti

Opportunity awaits on this 5.93-acre property featuring a 4-bedroom, 2-bath Cape Cod with plenty of space and potential. The home offers a functional layout and country setting, ready for a new owner to bring their vision and updates. Outside, you'll find a fenced pasture ideal for livestock or hobby farming, a large pole barn providing ample storage and workspace, and a covered back porch perfect for enjoying peaceful views of the property. Whether you're looking for a small farm, a place for horses, or simply room to spread out, this property offers endless possibilities. Home is being sold as-is and requires updating throughout, making it an excellent opportunity to build equity and create the rural retreat you've been dreaming of.

3844 Fisher Twin Road, West Alexandria

Courtesy of Tracey Bitonti and Irongate Inc.

$230,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 955935 MLS ⋅ Wendy L Muncy

Step into timeless elegance with this expansive 3,508 square foot, 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home featuring grand proportions and exquisite character throughout. This home’s construction was completed in 1875 boasting 11-foot ceilings on the first level, 11 ½-foot ceiling on the second level, oversized rooms, stunning hardwood floors, crown molding, a ceiling that features intricate, molded plaster medallions and border details suitable for this Victorian era home…this property offers both luxury and warmth in every detail. A truly beautiful “floating” staircase serves as the centerpiece of the home, complemented by rich natural butternut woodwork, intricate custom ceiling design of molded plaster medallions and border details (suitable for this Victorian style home) highlighting its historic charm along with transoms throughout the home that lend to the flow of air. With five fireplaces, each space feels inviting and full of personality. This property has a rich history in Preble County. Previously home to a successful restaurant, antique shop and tea room, this unique property offers dual zoning, making it ideal for residential living, a home-based business, or a live/work concept. There is an attached document to this listing detailing this exceptional home’s history. Additional features include an oversized 2-car detached garage with a large workshop, perfect for hobbyists or extra storage, newer HVAC in lower level of the home, original wood shutters, and the list continues on! This one-of-a-kind property is stately, spacious, full of opportunity and is primed and waiting for a new owner’s personal touch and preferences – both inside and out. Conveniently located between Dayton and Richmond, Indiana - an easy commute with small-town benefits. Make an appointment to view this property and see for yourself!

19 E Dayton Street, West Alexandria

Courtesy of Wendy L Muncy and Muncy & Associates

$299,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 954693 MLS ⋅ Kathi L Petelle

This charming four-bedroom, two-bath home, is full of timeless character and classic appeal. Featuring a solid brick exterior with large front porch and generously sized rooms throughout, the home offers high ceilings, spacious living and dining areas with beautiful built-in cabinets and plenty of natural light that enhances its historic charm. Each large bedroom provides ample closet space for comfort and flexibility, while the two full baths add everyday convenience. Upstairs windows were replaced in 2003. New well and sump pumps, new kitchen counters, backsplash, flooring, cooktop and dishwasher all in 2023. New dishwasher and refrigerator in 2020. New natural gas boiler in 2010 has been maintained yearly. Kitchen and bathroom windows were replaced in 2016. Original hardwood floors in most of the home. Four spacious bedrooms upstairs with plenty of closet space. The attic is partially floored for additional storage or could be turned into living space. The 3-car heated attached garage provides plenty of room for vehicles and storage plus provides direct access to the home into the laundry room. (which also includes a large built-in cabinet.) New garage doors in 2025. Garage roof was replaced in 2016. Situated on 1.77 acres, the property offers room to roam, garden, or simply enjoy country living. Covered front porch adds to the charm. Front yard is fenced for your small pets and children. A large 3-story barn with concrete floors and 4 stalls adds incredible value and versatility—perfect for storage, hobbies or workshop space. Barn roof was replaced in 2017.Combining vintage craftsmanship with wide-open space, this property is a rare opportunity to enjoy both history and functionality in a beautiful rural setting.

4515 State Route 35, West Alexandria

Courtesy of Kathi L Petelle and Irongate, Inc.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Elite Group - Coldwell Banker Heritage are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®